Civilization101Blueprint

Prevent deficiency disease

Keep a farming group from sickening on its own staple.

Tier 1 · Neolithic Health t1-nutrition Blocked by prerequisites
Dried maize (left) and the same maize after simmering and steeping in lime water (right): swollen, softened, skins loosened so they rub off. Only the right-hand kernels release their niacin to the body. Nixtamalized Corn maize El Salvador recipe · 2011-05-04 · Ll1324 · CC0 · Commons ↗

Everything for this step

Field guide
The body's numbers → 3 sections Biology → 19 sections
Builds
None yet.
Reference sheets
None.
Sciences it rests on
Medicine · Biology

Why this matters

Farming solves the calorie problem and narrows the diet. Scurvy, pellagra, beriberi, goitre, rickets and vitamin A blindness all appear after the harvest succeeds, in the people eating most of one grain. Each has a fix available at this tier, and each has killed on a large scale where the fix was unknown or lost: pellagra alone caused an estimated 3 million cases and 100,000 deaths in the US South between 1906 and 1940, on maize that Mesoamerica had been eating safely for about 3,000 years.

The shape of it

  1. Count food groups, not meals. A woman who ate from 5 of 10 food groups yesterday is likely to be getting her micronutrients; fewer than 5 means something is missing.
  2. Never eat maize untreated. Cook it in lime or wood-ash water until the skins slip, then rinse — or the population gets pellagra.
  3. Parboil rice before milling, or eat it brown. White rice without other thiamine sources causes beriberi.
  4. Eat a vitamin C source every day, and plan for late winter: raw greens, sauerkraut, potatoes, sprouted seed. About 10 mg a day prevents scurvy.
  5. Bring iodine inland — sea fish, seaweed or iodised salt. Inland and mountain soils are short of it, and deficiency in pregnancy damages the child's brain permanently.
  6. Give children and mothers sun, fat and colour: midday sun for vitamin D; liver, egg and orange or dark green plants for vitamin A.
  7. Wean onto thick food, and measure every young child's upper arm monthly.
  8. Check every household at the end of winter for the early signs, and answer each with food the same day.

Doing it, step by step

The summary above says what has to happen. This says how, with the numbers that decide whether it works.

1 · Count food groups, not meals

A full stomach says nothing about vitamins and minerals. The field measure is dietary diversity: ask a woman of childbearing age what she ate yesterday, and count how many of these 10 groups appear.

  1. Grains, white roots and tubers
  2. Pulses — beans, peas, lentils
  3. Nuts and seeds
  4. Milk and milk products
  5. Meat, poultry and fish
  6. Eggs
  7. Dark green leafy vegetables
  8. Other vitamin A-rich fruit and vegetables — orange flesh: carrot, pumpkin, mango, orange sweet potato
  9. Other vegetables
  10. Other fruit

Five or more groups is FAO's threshold (the MDD-W indicator) for a diet likely to meet micronutrient needs. Women are counted because pregnancy and breastfeeding raise their needs most, so a diet that passes for them usually passes for the household.

Count again at the end of winter. Stores narrow the diet to grain, and that is when deficiency starts.

✓ Check: Recalls from several households, taken in late winter, reach five or more groups — and where they do not, the missing groups are named and a source is planned for each.

2 · Maize: cook every batch in alkali

Maize holds its niacin (vitamin B3) in a bound form the gut cannot release, and is poor in tryptophan, from which the body makes niacin. A population living on untreated maize gets pellagra: a symmetrical, sharp-edged rash on skin the sun reaches — backs of the hands, forearms, a band round the neck — then diarrhoea, then confusion and dementia, then death. Cases rise in spring, after a winter on stored maize.

Nixtamalise — the Mesoamerican method, in use for about 3,000 years:

  1. Per 1 kg of dried maize: 3 litres of water and 10 g of slaked lime (calcium hydroxide) — 1% of the grain's weight. Without lime, use hardwood-ash lye: stir ash into water, let it settle, and use the clear liquid. Its strength varies, so judge it by the next step.
  2. Simmer 20–40 minutes, stirring, until the skin of a test kernel rubs off between finger and thumb.
  3. Cover and steep 8–16 hours.
  4. Drain and rinse in several changes of water, rubbing, until the water runs clear and the kernels no longer feel slippery.
  5. Grind wet to dough, or cook whole as hominy.

Eat beans with maize. Beans supply the tryptophan maize lacks; maize, beans and squash together is the diet that did not produce pellagra.

Dried maize (left) and the same maize after simmering and steeping in lime water (right): swollen, softened, skins loosened so they rub off. Only the right-hand kernels release their niacin to the body. Nixtamalized Corn maize El Salvador recipe · 2011-05-04 · Ll1324 · CC0 · Commons ↗
Use slaked lime, never quicklime — quicklime boils violently when wetted. Lime and ash lye are caustic: keep them out of eyes, and never skip the rinse.
✓ Check: Every batch of maize eaten has been simmered in lime or ash water until the skins slip, steeped and rinsed; untreated maize meal is nobody's daily food.

3 · Rice: parboil before milling, or eat it brown

Thiamine (vitamin B1) sits in the bran and germ, which milling removes: white rice has lost most of its thiamine. The body holds only about 25–30 mg — a few weeks' supply — so a diet of polished rice produces beriberi:

  • Dry beriberi — numb, weak legs and a stumbling walk.
  • Wet beriberi — swollen legs, breathlessness, a failing heart.
  • Infantile beriberi — in breastfed babies of deficient mothers, usually at 2–6 months: a hoarse or silent cry, vomiting, fast breathing. It can kill within hours.

Parboiling drives the thiamine into the grain while it is still in the husk:

  1. Soak the paddy — rice still in its husk — overnight in cold water, or 3–4 hours at 60–70 °C: too hot to hold a hand in, well short of boiling.
  2. Drain and steam 10–20 minutes, until a few husks split.
  3. Dry in a thin layer, turned often, down to about 14% moisture. Drying too fast in strong sun cracks the grains.
  4. Mill as usual. Parboiled rice keeps more thiamine through milling and breaks less.

Or mill lightly and eat the rice brown. Either way, do not wash rice repeatedly or pour away its cooking water — thiamine dissolves into it. Pulses and groundnuts eaten with rice supply thiamine too.

Parboiling: soaked paddy — rice still in its husk — tipped out after steaming. Steaming in the husk drives thiamine from the bran into the grain, where milling cannot remove it. A woman prepares parboiled rice · 2016-12-03 06:01:16 · Nduati.githae · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Commons ↗
Parboiled paddy spread thin on sheets to dry before milling. It has to come down to about 14% moisture or it cracks in the mill and moulds in store. Parboiled rice drying · 2017-09-23 12:35:15 · Oklo2020 · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Commons ↗
✓ Check: Rice eaten daily is parboiled or lightly milled and cooked in only as much water as it absorbs, and every nursing mother eats pulses, groundnuts, whole grain or meat every day.

4 · Vitamin C every day — most of all in late winter

The body cannot make vitamin C and holds about 1,500 mg. With none in the diet, scurvy appears within about 1–3 months: tiredness and aching legs, then gums swollen, dark and bleeding, bruising at a touch, pinpoint bleeds around the hair follicles of the legs, old wounds reopening, then death. About 10 mg a day prevents it; aim for 50–100 mg for margin.

Vitamin C per 100 g, approximately:

  • Rose hips, fresh: over 400 mg
  • Blackcurrants: about 180 mg
  • Kale, raw: about 90–120 mg
  • Lemon juice, fresh: about 40 mg
  • Cabbage, raw: about 35 mg
  • Sauerkraut: about 15 mg
  • Mung bean or lentil sprouts, 2–4 days old: about 13–17 mg
  • Potatoes, boiled in their skins: about 13 mg
  • Dried grain, dried beans, dried or salted meat: almost none

Heat, air, time and copper destroy it. Eat greens raw where they have been washed in safe water; cook briefly in little water and drink the water; never store juice in copper.

Sprout seed in late winter: soak dried peas, beans or lentils 8–12 hours, drain, rinse twice a day in safe water, and eat raw at 2–4 days — the sprouting seed makes vitamin C the dry seed lacks. 100 g a day of sauerkraut, potatoes or sprouts covers the minimum through the hungry gap.

Treat scurvy the same day with the richest raw source available. The gums improve within days.

Scurvy: gums swollen, dark and spongy between the teeth, bleeding at the gum line. With easy bruising and pinpoint bleeds around the hair follicles of the legs, this is the sign to act on — weeks before scurvy kills. Scorbutic gums · 1970 · Centers for Disease Control and Prevention · Public domain · Commons ↗
Mung beans after about three days of sprouting. Dried beans carry little vitamin C; sprouts like these carry about 13 mg per 100 g — eaten raw, 100 g a day holds off scurvy. Homegrown-mung-bean-sprouts · 2011-03-27 · Harduser · CC0 · Commons ↗
Never sprout or eat seed dressed with fungicide — seed grain treated for sowing, usually dyed pink, red or blue. In Iraq in 1971–72, mercury-treated seed grain baked into bread killed 459 people.
✓ Check: In the last month before the first spring greens, every person has a named daily vitamin C source, and nobody has bleeding gums.

5 · Iodine: bring it inland

Glaciation, heavy rain and flooding wash iodine out of soil, so inland, mountain and river-valley settlements grow food short of it; coastal diets rarely are. Adults need about 150 µg a day, 250 µg in pregnancy.

  • Goitre — a soft swelling at the front of the neck that rises when the person swallows. It shows the population is short.
  • Deficiency in pregnancy is the serious harm: stillbirth, and cretinism — permanent intellectual disability, deafness and stunting in the child. WHO calls iodine deficiency the world's leading preventable cause of brain damage.

A goitre in more than 5% of schoolchildren (WHO's threshold) marks the whole settlement as iodine-poor.

Sources, most reliable first:

  • Sea fish and shellfish, eaten weekly.
  • Kelp (kombu) — commonly 1,000–3,000 µg per gram dried, and highly variable, so about 1 g a week covers an adult. The thyroid stores iodine, so weekly intake is enough. Wakame and nori carry far less.
  • Iodised salt, once iodine can be made or traded: 20–40 mg of iodine per kg of salt (WHO range). Switzerland began iodising salt in 1922, and endemic cretinism there disappeared.
Kelp (kombu) hung to dry in Hokkaido. Dried kelp is the richest food source of iodine: about 1 g a week covers an adult, and a daily handful causes thyroid disease of its own. Japan, Hokkaido, drying kelp 2 · 1987 · Marie-Sophie Mejan · CC BY 4.0 · Commons ↗
Do not eat kelp daily by the handful. Long intake above about 1,100 µg of iodine a day causes thyroid disease of its own.
✓ Check: The settlement knows whether its ground is iodine-poor, and every pregnant woman has a weekly source — sea fish, measured seaweed or iodised salt.

6 · Sun, fat and colour for children and mothers

Vitamin D is made in skin by midday sun. Beyond about 35–37° latitude, north or south, the winter sun is too low to make any for several months. Children in cold climates, children kept indoors or fully wrapped, and dark-skinned children at high latitude get rickets: soft bones, legs that bow once walking starts, a row of knobs down the ribs, late walking. Girls with rickets grow a narrowed pelvis, which made obstructed labour common a generation later.

  • Summer: arms and face in midday sun 5–30 minutes, two or three times a week for pale skin, several times longer for dark skin. Stop before the skin reddens.
  • Winter and high latitude: oily fish two or three times a week, and eggs.
  • Cod-liver oil works, with a limit. One 5 ml teaspoon carries about 11 µg of vitamin D — a child needs 10–15 µg a day — but also about 1,350 µg of vitamin A, against an upper limit of 600 µg a day for a child under 4. Give small children no more than half a teaspoon, and none on days they eat liver.

Vitamin A is stored in the liver, so deficiency comes slowly, then fast:

  1. Night blindness — a child who cannot see at dusk when others can. This is the sign to act on.
  2. Dry, dull whites of the eye, with foamy grey patches (Bitot's spots).
  3. Softening of the cornea, then permanent blindness.

Deficiency also raises deaths from measles and diarrhoea: correcting it in deficient populations cuts child deaths by roughly 12–24%. Sources: liver (a small portion once a week is plenty), eggs and milk fat, and orange and dark green plants — carrot, orange sweet potato, pumpkin, mango, dark leaves, red palm oil. Plant carotene needs fat in the same meal to be absorbed.

Never eat the liver of a polar bear, seal or husky. One meal can carry a lethal dose of vitamin A.
✓ Check: Every child under five eats a vitamin A source at least twice a week and has a vitamin D source through the winter, and no child in the group stumbles at dusk.

7 · Wean onto food thick enough to grow on

Malnutrition kills most between 6 months and 2 years, when breast milk stops being enough on its own and the food added to it is too thin. A small child eats about 30 g per kg of body weight at a meal. A watery gruel carries 0.3–0.4 kcal per gram; a child needs food nearer 0.8–1 kcal per gram to meet its needs in the meals it can hold.

  • Breastfeed alone to 6 months, then keep breastfeeding to 2 years alongside food.
  • From 6 months, porridge thick enough to stay on a tilted spoon — not a gruel that runs off it.
  • Thicken with energy, not water: stir a spoon of oil or fat, mashed pulses, groundnut paste, egg or fish into every meal.
  • Malted flour lets porridge be thick and still swallowable: sprout grain 1–2 days, dry it and grind it, and stir a pinch into cooked thick porridge. Its enzymes thin it without adding water.
  • Meals: 2–3 a day at 6–8 months, 3–4 a day at 9–23 months, plus 1–2 snacks.

Measure the arm. Mark a strip of cloth at 11.5 cm and 12.5 cm, and wrap it round the middle of the left upper arm of every child aged 6 months to 5 years, monthly:

  • Under 11.5 cm, or swelling of both feet — severe acute malnutrition, a medical emergency.
  • 11.5–12.5 cm — moderate: enrich every meal and measure again at the next check.
  • Over 12.5 cm — adequate.
✓ Check: Every child aged 6–23 months eats thick, enriched porridge at the right number of meals, and every child aged 6 months to 5 years has a monthly arm measurement above 12.5 cm.

8 · Check every household at the end of winter

Deficiencies come together, in the same people and the same season. Once a year, when stores are lowest, look for these and answer each with food that day:

  • Bleeding, swollen gums; bruising; pinpoint bleeds on the shins — vitamin C: raw greens, sprouts, sauerkraut, fruit, daily.
  • A sharp-edged rash on the backs of the hands, forearms or neck; diarrhoea — niacin: nixtamalised maize, beans, groundnuts, meat, fish.
  • Numb or weak legs, swollen legs, breathlessness — thiamine: parboiled or brown rice, pulses, groundnuts.
  • A child who cannot see at dusk; dry, dull whites of the eye — vitamin A: liver, egg, orange or dark green plants eaten with fat.
  • A toddler's legs bowing; late walking — vitamin D: midday sun, oily fish, egg.
  • A neck swelling that rises on swallowing — iodine: sea fish, measured seaweed, iodised salt.
  • Pale inner eyelids, breathlessness, exhaustion — iron: meat, liver, pulses eaten with vitamin C; no tea with meals, which blocks absorption.
  • An upper arm under 12.5 cm, or swollen feet, in a young child — energy and protein: thick enriched porridge. Under 11.5 cm, or both feet swollen, is an emergency.

For treatment beyond food — doses, and the severe cases — use a current manual such as Hesperian's Where There Is No Doctor.

✓ Check: An end-of-winter check has covered every household, and every positive finding has a food response that started the same day.

What it looks like

Scurvy: gums swollen, dark and spongy between the teeth, bleeding at the gum line. With easy bruising and pinpoint bleeds around the hair follicles of the legs, this is the sign to act on — weeks before scurvy kills. Scorbutic gums · 1970 · Centers for Disease Control and Prevention · Public domain · Commons ↗
Mung beans after about three days of sprouting. Dried beans carry little vitamin C; sprouts like these carry about 13 mg per 100 g — eaten raw, 100 g a day holds off scurvy. Homegrown-mung-bean-sprouts · 2011-03-27 · Harduser · CC0 · Commons ↗
Parboiling: soaked paddy — rice still in its husk — tipped out after steaming. Steaming in the husk drives thiamine from the bran into the grain, where milling cannot remove it. A woman prepares parboiled rice · 2016-12-03 06:01:16 · Nduati.githae · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Commons ↗
Kelp (kombu) hung to dry in Hokkaido. Dried kelp is the richest food source of iodine: about 1 g a week covers an adult, and a daily handful causes thyroid disease of its own. Japan, Hokkaido, drying kelp 2 · 1987 · Marie-Sophie Mejan · CC BY 4.0 · Commons ↗
Parboiled paddy spread thin on sheets to dry before milling. It has to come down to about 14% moisture or it cracks in the mill and moulds in store. Parboiled rice drying · 2017-09-23 12:35:15 · Oklo2020 · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Commons ↗

The better path

What the record shows was done at this step, what to do instead at this tier, and the evidence. All of them: the better path.

Adopt earlier

Citrus and greens against scurvy

What was done
Navies and expeditions sailed on dried and salted food for three centuries. Lemon juice was recommended against scurvy by 1617, trialled in 1747, and issued in the Royal Navy only from 1795 — and the knowledge was then lost again.
Do instead
Give anyone living on stored food a raw vitamin C source every day: greens, sprouts, sauerkraut, potatoes or fruit. About 10 mg a day prevents scurvy.
Evidence
James Lind's 1747 trial on HMS Salisbury split 12 scurvy patients into six pairs; the pair given oranges and lemons recovered fastest, one fit for duty within six days. In the 1860s the Navy switched to West Indian lime juice, which carries less vitamin C and was stored for long periods, and scurvy returned on the British Arctic Expedition of 1875–76.

Needs: Forage, trap, fish, Preserve the harvest

Adopt earlier

Cook maize in alkali

What was done
Maize spread from the Americas to Europe, Africa and the US South after 1500 without nixtamalisation — the processing step that had made it a safe staple where it came from.
Do instead
Simmer every batch of maize in 1% slaked lime or wood-ash lye until the skins slip, steep it overnight and rinse it; eat beans with it.
Evidence
Pellagra was described in Spain in 1735 and became endemic in northern Italy. In the US South an estimated 3 million cases and 100,000 deaths followed between 1906 and 1940. Joseph Goldberger showed from 1914 that the cause was diet, not infection; niacin was identified as the missing factor in 1937. Mesoamerican evidence for nixtamalisation dates to about 1500–1200 BC.

Needs: Plant staples, Fire, and keeping it

Adopt earlier

Parboil rice before milling

What was done
From the late 19th century, mechanical mills made polished white rice cheap across Asia, and beriberi spread with it among those who ate the most of it: sailors, soldiers, prisoners and city workers.
Do instead
Soak and steam paddy in its husk before milling, or eat rice lightly milled; eat pulses or groundnuts with it.
Evidence
Japanese Navy: on the nine-month voyage of the training ship Ryūjō in 1882–83, 169 of 376 crew developed beriberi and 25 died. Kanehiro Takaki sent the Tsukuba on the same route in 1884 with barley, meat and milk added to the rice: 14 cases, all among men who had not eaten the new ration, and no deaths.

Needs: Plant staples, Pottery and the first kiln

How this fails

Adopting a crop without the processing that made it safe where it came from — maize without alkali, bitter cassava without soaking and fermenting.
Milling all the rice white because it stores and sells better, and losing the thiamine with the bran.
Assuming stored food still carries vitamin C. Drying, long boiling and months in store destroy most of it.
Treating night blindness in a child, bleeding gums or a rash on sun-exposed skin as minor. Each is an early sign with weeks to act.
Correcting iodine with kelp by the handful every day — too much iodine causes thyroid disease too.
Weaning onto thin gruel, which fills a small stomach without feeding it.

How you know it worked

VerificationThrough a full year including late winter, nobody shows bleeding gums, night blindness, a rash on sun-exposed skin or a new goitre; every household can name its vitamin C source for March; and every child aged 6 months to 5 years measures above 12.5 cm round the upper arm.